ATLANTIC CITY, N.J. — A clash between union leaders has reignited tensions over a long-standing issue: smoking in Atlantic City casinos. On Monday, a rival union official demanded the resignation of Donna DeCaprio, president of Local 54 of the Unite Here union, accusing her of prioritizing casino profits over the health of workers.
Workers Demand Protection From Secondhand Smoke
The controversy stems from Local 54’s opposition to a proposed smoking ban in Atlantic City casinos. DeCaprio’s union argues that banning smoking could drive away gamblers, leading to potential closures of casinos and widespread job losses.
Ray Jensen, assistant director of United Auto Workers (UAW) Region 9, which represents dealers at three Atlantic City casinos, criticized DeCaprio’s position. Jensen called her stance a betrayal of workers’ rights and urged her to resign.
“She should be ashamed of herself,” Jensen said. “She should hand in her union card.”
Jensen’s UAW is actively involved in a lawsuit seeking to force an end to smoking in casinos, aligning with other groups advocating for stricter public health policies.
The Case Against a Smoking Ban
DeCaprio defended her position, emphasizing the need for balance. While acknowledging the dangers of secondhand smoke, she pointed to the potential economic fallout of a smoking ban.
“A balance needs to be reached that will both protect worker health and preserve good jobs,” DeCaprio said. “We are protecting our members against multiple casino closures and job losses. The UAW is eager to sacrifice the entire casino industry and put 25,000 good jobs with benefits at risk.”
Local 54 has maintained that a sudden smoking ban could lead to significant revenue losses, as many gamblers are smokers. According to a 2022 study commissioned by the Casino Association of New Jersey, smoking bans in other jurisdictions have caused double-digit revenue drops for gaming establishments.
Health Versus Jobs
At the heart of the issue is the health of casino workers, many of whom are exposed to secondhand smoke for hours each day. Anti-smoking advocates, including employees and public health organizations, argue that no job is worth risking long-term health.
• Secondhand Smoke Risks: According to the CDC, secondhand smoke exposure increases the risk of heart disease, stroke, and lung cancer in non-smokers.
• Industry Opposition: Casino operators and some unions, like Local 54, argue that allowing limited smoking sections minimizes harm while preserving customer satisfaction.
Despite efforts to accommodate both sides, tensions remain high. Workers have protested outside casinos, and advocacy groups have repeatedly called on New Jersey lawmakers to eliminate the exemption that allows indoor smoking in casinos.
Broader Implications for Atlantic City
The debate extends beyond health and jobs, touching on the broader economic stability of Atlantic City. Casinos are a key economic driver, employing tens of thousands and generating significant tax revenue.
Yet, as more states adopt smoking bans in public spaces, including casinos, the pressure on Atlantic City’s operators is growing. Neighboring states like New York already enforce strict no-smoking rules, raising questions about whether New Jersey’s policies are sustainable.
Both sides agree on one thing: the need for a healthier, more secure future for casino workers. How to achieve that, however, remains deeply contested.
